From "Symposia of the Society for the Study of Human Biology" "Natural Selection in Man" - University College, London, 1958 Published as "Natural Selection in Human Populations" Editors D F Roberts and G A Harrison Pergamon Press - London - 1959 Quote from Theodosius Dobzhansky - Department of Zoology Columbia University, New York City. "On selection of Gene Systems in Natural Populations" "Although Morgan saw clearly that "... the whole germ plasm, the sum of all the genes, acts in the formation of every detail of the body ...", the semantic habits of geneticists conspired to conceal this fact. We still speak of the gene "for" the blood group A, the haemophilia gene, the achondroplasia gene in Man, the gene "for" resistance to DDT in the house fly, and "for" resistance to the newest antibiotic in bacteria. Recent work in genetics has shown that the atomism of heredity is actually not as thorough- going as it was believed earlier. The form of discourse accepted in genetics is liable to generate pseudo-problems. What, for example, was the gene for DDT resistance doing in the house flies during the aeons of time before DDT was discovered? The development is brought about by the genotype; the constellation of genes, acting in concert, and interacting with the environment. There is no gene "for" DDT resistance in flies, although the difference between the resistant and the non-resistant flies may be conditioned by one gene, or by a small group of genes." ---------------------------------------- Dobzhansky later quotes Morgan's dictum: "all the genes that an organism possesses participate in the formation of every detail of the body" ---------------------------------------- "Perceptions" note: This seems to confirm our own conclusion - that the addition, subtraction or change of even one gene, for "genetic engineering" purposes, will necessarily cause unknown (and unknowable) changes / damage in the whole organism. We say that if this is done in a human being then a "non-human" inevitably results, no matter how small the projected change and no matter how confident the "genetic engineer" professes to be. ---------------------------------------- Evidence page for http://www.perceptions.couk.com/genes8.html ---------------------------------------- FURTHER REFERENCES GO - "search perceptions" - in SEARCH-ENGINE file-ID www.perceptions.couk.com/gentruth.txt